BarBella Box grew 687.8% in subscribers and increased revenue 7x in one year by switching to a membership model. Their success came from targeting female CrossFit athletes, offering tailored subscription tiers, and building a connected community. Key takeaways:
- Membership Tiers: Three levels ($29.99, $49.99, $79.99/month) with increasing benefits like exclusive products, coaching, and events.
- Retention Focus: Achieved a 91% retention rate by creating a loyal community and offering flexible subscription options.
- Marketing Strategy: Leveraged email campaigns (70% of new members), influencer partnerships, and a referral program to attract the right audience.
- Community Engagement: Virtual training, private groups, and challenges kept members invested.
- Upselling: Exclusive bundles, tier upgrades, and loyalty points boosted revenue from existing members.
The result? A thriving subscription business that prioritized retention, community, and personalized value over one-time sales.
What’s Working Now: Memberships That Scale Without Burnout with Stu McLaren
Company Background and Why They Chose Membership
BarBella Box wasn’t Ozery’s first business venture, but it was the perfect blend of her marketing expertise and her passion for CrossFit. Before launching the subscription service, Ozery had already built a strong foundation in marketing – a skill set that proved invaluable in navigating the competitive fitness market.
The company entered a landscape dominated by traditional retailers relying on one-off sales. In this model, customers often shopped around for the best deals, rarely forming lasting connections with any one brand. While this approach worked for larger companies with extensive inventories and deep financial resources, it posed serious challenges for startups like BarBella Box. At the same time, the fitness industry was evolving, with specialized niches emerging. Many female CrossFit athletes felt underserved by mainstream brands, which often came across as either too generic or overly focused on male consumers.
Problems They Faced and Market Conditions
The traditional retail model came with its own set of challenges. High customer acquisition costs and low retention rates meant that profits were often squeezed as customers easily jumped to competitors offering better deals.
Meanwhile, consumer preferences were shifting. People were looking for more specialized communities and experiences. This trend, combined with the rise of recurring revenue models, created an opening for a different approach. In fact, subscription-based businesses were growing their revenue nine times faster than companies relying on one-off purchases.
Making the Switch Decision
Confronted with these obstacles, Ozery recognized the need for a new strategy. The subscription model offered a way to stabilize income while cutting marketing costs. By focusing on retaining members and increasing customer lifetime value (CLV), BarBella Box could shift its energy from constant customer acquisition to building deeper relationships.
Moving away from single transactions, the membership model naturally encouraged customer loyalty. This decision wasn’t just a practical response to market challenges; it also aligned with larger industry trends. Between January 2012 and June 2019, subscription businesses grew their revenue nearly five times faster than both the retail sector and the S&P 500.
But BarBella Box wasn’t just about selling products. The membership approach allowed the company to create a community-driven experience. Female CrossFit athletes weren’t just looking for gear – they wanted to connect with others who shared their passion and find products that truly supported their training goals. By focusing on recurring relationships, BarBella Box turned market challenges into an opportunity to foster loyalty and build a thriving community.
How They Built and Launched Their Membership Model
BarBella Box took a thoughtful approach to creating its membership model, focusing on what its community of female CrossFit enthusiasts truly valued. Instead of overcomplicating things with a multi-layered system, the company zeroed in on simplicity and relevance, using research and planning to shape its offerings around customer preferences and spending habits.
Membership Levels and What Members Get
The membership structure was designed with three clear tiers, each offering a balance of affordability and benefits tailored to different needs:
- Essential Tier ($29.99/month): This entry-level option provided 3–4 handpicked fitness products, workout guides crafted by female CrossFit athletes, and priority customer support. It was aimed at beginners or those seeking high-quality gear without a significant financial commitment.
- Elite Tier ($49.99/month): Members received 5–6 premium products, early access to limited-edition items, monthly virtual training sessions, and access to a private online community. Pre-launch surveys confirmed the price point resonated with the audience.
- Champion Tier ($79.99/month): Designed for the most dedicated athletes, this tier included 7–8 top-tier products, one-on-one monthly coaching calls, exclusive merchandise, and invitations to in-person events.
All tiers came with free U.S. shipping, a satisfaction guarantee, and flexible options to pause, skip, or cancel subscriptions. This flexibility reduced the hesitation often tied to long-term commitments and made the membership feel low-risk.
With these tiers in place, BarBella Box set the stage for a strategic launch to gauge interest and refine its approach.
Launch Process
To roll out the membership model, BarBella Box utilized a seed launch strategy. A 30-day pre-launch campaign in March 2019 highlighted curated products and inspiring stories from female athletes. Live video sessions on Instagram and Facebook drew significant attention, with 22.7% of viewers actively engaging with the streams.
When the membership officially launched, the company offered a limited-time discount for founding members and introduced an affiliate program. This program rewarded referrals with account credits, creating an incentive for early adopters to spread the word. These efforts validated customer interest, brought in early revenue, and allowed BarBella Box to fine-tune its operations.
Membership Structure Options Compared
Before settling on its three-tier system, BarBella Box explored other models, including single-tier, quality-based, usage-based, and freemium options. Ultimately, the three-tier approach won out due to its scalability and ability to clearly differentiate value across levels. By keeping the structure simple yet appealing, the company avoided overwhelming potential members while creating natural opportunities for upselling.
Each tier was designed to deliver a clear and compelling set of benefits, tailored to the needs of their CrossFit community. At the same time, the streamlined structure kept operations manageable, ensuring the company could scale effectively as membership grew.
sbb-itb-32a2de3
How They Grew Their Membership Revenue
After establishing their membership structure, BarBella Box shifted its focus to two critical goals: attracting the right members and keeping them engaged. They honed in on three key strategies that drove their success. Let’s break it down.
Finding the Right Customers and Marketing to Them
BarBella Box faced a tough challenge – growing their membership base by 68%. To tackle this, they created detailed member personas using data from their existing customers. Their marketing efforts zeroed in on platforms where their audience was most active, with social media and email marketing leading the charge. In fact, email campaigns alone brought in nearly 70% of new members.
The company collaborated with influencers who genuinely used and endorsed their products. These partnerships produced content that highlighted both the quality of their offerings and the benefits of being part of the BarBella Box community. On top of that, they segmented their email lists by factors like engagement and demographics, ensuring messages felt personal and relevant. For example, pre-launch subscribers got early access offers, while prospective members received educational content about the perks of joining.
To sweeten the deal, BarBella Box launched a referral program. Members earned account credits for successful referrals, turning loyal customers into brand ambassadors. They also ran targeted Google Ads that directed potential members to landing pages featuring testimonials and product highlights – proving that quality traffic is all about the right audience.
Building a Connected Community
BarBella Box understood an essential truth: customers who feel connected to a brand are 52% more valuable – they buy more, stick around longer, and spread the word. To nurture this connection, they created a vibrant community through several initiatives.
Their private member group became a hub for interaction, while regular virtual sessions hosted by professional trainers built a sense of belonging. They also kept members engaged with event calendars, personalized communication, and regional meetups. These efforts weren’t just about selling products – they were about creating a tribe.
"Build a tribe, not a buyer base." – Seth Godin
Monthly virtual sessions turned into a cornerstone of their community strategy, drawing strong participation and fostering networking opportunities. Challenges added another layer of excitement, with prizes like exclusive merchandise and public recognition. This not only encouraged healthy competition but also deepened brand loyalty. The result? A highly engaged community ready to explore more of what BarBella Box had to offer.
Selling More to Existing Members
Once they had an active and loyal member base, BarBella Box focused on increasing revenue from existing customers. After all, stats show that current customers are 60–70% more likely to make a purchase compared to new prospects.
They offered limited-time tier upgrades at discounted rates, often timed around key membership milestones. Testimonials from members who had upgraded and enjoyed enhanced benefits helped drive these offers home. Additionally, exclusive product bundles – only available to members – were introduced, combining popular items at discounted prices. These bundles were promoted through personalized emails tailored to members’ past preferences.
To keep things fresh, BarBella Box launched limited-edition products exclusively for members. Access was staggered by membership tier, giving members a reason to consider upgrading. Cross-selling opportunities were also baked into their strategy, using educational content to highlight product benefits and offering member-exclusive discounts on featured items.
The company also implemented a loyalty points system. Members earned credits for activities like referrals, social media shares, and community participation. These points could be redeemed for exclusive products or membership upgrades. By focusing on well-timed, personalized offers – especially when members were highly engaged or had recently shared positive feedback – BarBella Box boosted customer lifetime value by 20–40%.
Their approach shows how a mix of community building, personalized marketing, and strategic upselling can turn members into long-term advocates while driving revenue growth.
Results and What They Learned
Eighteen months after introducing their tiered membership structure, BarBella Box hit some impressive milestones: 321 annual memberships and $100,000 in revenue. Their website also saw a boost in engagement, with a 28% increase in average session duration, as members spent more time exploring exclusive content and community features.
One standout metric was member retention. BarBella Box achieved retention rates on par with industry leaders, and members who stayed beyond their first year spent up to 70% more annually . By prioritizing upselling and cross-selling to existing members, they drove meaningful revenue growth.
However, their journey wasn’t without its challenges. Along the way, they had to tackle several operational hurdles and adjust their strategies to stay on track.
Problems They Solved Along the Way
Billing and Payment Management was a significant obstacle. Issues like recurring payments, failed transactions, and involuntary churn prompted the need for system upgrades. Inspired by companies like Cafeyn, which reduced involuntary churn by 90% through subscription management platforms, BarBella Box implemented automated billing systems. This upgrade helped them manage the complexities of their tiered structure while minimizing manual errors.
Customer Data Complexity added another layer of difficulty. Unlike traditional one-time purchases, memberships required meticulous tracking of billing cycles, contract terms, renewal dates, usage patterns, and pricing tiers. Revenue leakage caused by human error – estimated at 0.25% to 1% of top-line revenue – highlighted the need for automated data management systems to improve accuracy and efficiency.
Scaling Too Quickly posed a potential risk to their progress. They took a lesson from RewardMe, a company that secured a $1.5 million deal but struggled with cash flow and eventually shut down. To avoid a similar fate, BarBella Box chose to prioritize sustainable growth over rapid expansion, ensuring their operations could support their goals before scaling further.
Another challenge was maintaining ongoing value for members. With nearly 40% of consumers canceling subscriptions within six months, BarBella Box had to consistently demonstrate their worth. This meant regularly updating product offerings, enhancing community features, and using feedback loops to stay aligned with member needs.
These challenges helped shape their approach, offering valuable lessons for building a sustainable membership model.
Key Lessons for Other Businesses
Invest in Infrastructure Early. Companies like On The Map Marketing saved 15 hours monthly on billing and recovered $600,000 annually by adopting intelligent billing platforms. BarBella Box realized that effective subscription management isn’t just about collecting payments – it’s about creating smooth, hassle-free customer experiences while reducing administrative work.
Retention Beats Acquisition. The numbers back it up: improving customer retention by just 1% can boost the bottom line by 6.71%. BarBella Box focused on community building, personalized communication, and ongoing engagement to secure long-term returns, rather than pouring resources into acquiring new members.
Know Your Customer Journey Inside and Out. Membership models require a deep understanding of what attracts and retains customers, as well as what causes them to leave. BarBella Box adopted robust tracking and feedback systems to monitor satisfaction and address potential churn risks before they became major issues.
Prepare for Operational Complexity. With the subscription economy projected to hit $1.5 trillion by 2025 and 75% of B2C businesses expected to embrace this model, it’s clear that success requires more than just switching to recurring payments. BarBella Box learned to anticipate the added workload of managing ongoing relationships and built systems strong enough to support sustainable growth.
Conclusion
BarBella Box’s shift from traditional sales to a membership-based model brought remarkable results – achieving a 687.8% increase in subscribers and 7x revenue growth in just one year.
This success highlights the potential of membership models, which offer several key benefits: they enable more accurate profit forecasting for improved cash flow management, foster customer loyalty and community through regular interaction, and reduce costs significantly – retaining existing customers is up to five times cheaper than acquiring new ones. However, it’s not just about switching to subscriptions; businesses must consistently deliver value to keep customers engaged.
Strong coaching cultures also play a pivotal role in business success, boosting revenue by 51% and improving performance and communication for 70% of clients. As Brian Spear of Sunrise Capital Investors explains:
"A good business coach does not tell you what to do. Rather, they act as a mentor, guide, and sounding board, helping you maximize your potential, avoid costly mistakes, and achieve your business goals more efficiently".
These insights underline the importance of strategic guidance when navigating the complexities of membership models. This is where M Accelerator excels, blending strategy, execution, and communication to help businesses replicate successes like BarBella Box’s. With a track record of supporting over 500 founders and facilitating more than $50M in funding, M Accelerator ensures that bold visions turn into actionable results.
A well-executed membership model, supported by the right infrastructure and expert advice, offers businesses a scalable path to long-term growth – transforming how they approach revenue generation.
FAQs
What helped BarBella Box achieve such a high retention rate with their membership model?
BarBella Box maintained an impressive retention rate by delivering carefully selected fitness products tailored specifically for women. By focusing on items that were relevant and appealing, they ensured their subscribers felt the value in every box. Their dependable monthly deliveries added a layer of trust and reliability, while the community-driven approach surrounding their brand encouraged stronger connections and loyalty among members. Together, these elements created a subscription experience that kept customers coming back for more.
How did BarBella Box grow its membership using influencer marketing and email campaigns?
BarBella Box saw impressive growth in its membership by blending influencer marketing with carefully planned email campaigns. Founder Ella Ozery leveraged her background in fitness and her enthusiasm for the CrossFit lifestyle to resonate with the female CrossFit community. By collaborating with influencers, she expanded the brand’s visibility across social media platforms, reaching a highly engaged audience.
To complement this, Ella initiated prelaunch email campaigns designed to build anticipation, grow a subscriber list, and create buzz ahead of the official launch. This well-executed strategy paid off, driving a 7x increase in revenue within just one year.
How did BarBella Box successfully scale its subscription-based business and address growth challenges?
BarBella Box grew its subscription-based business by honing in on niche targeting, prioritizing customer retention, and emphasizing community engagement. By tapping into marketing strategies tailored to subscription models and using tools specifically designed for this purpose, they successfully reached their ideal audience and built a loyal subscriber base.
These focused efforts allowed them to tackle growth hurdles effectively, resulting in a sharp rise in subscribers and a notable boost in revenue.
